Enforcing Pay Equity Rights
Mary Cornish and Ryan White for The Lawyers Weekly
July 9, 2010
With women comprising nearly half of Canada's paid workforce and performing work crucial to the nation's economic recovery, employers and governments are being increasingly challenged to close the 29 per cent gender pay gap. This gap is even larger among women who are immigrants, racialized, aboriginal and/or disabled. The pay gap is not only a human rights violation, but a barrier to Canada's economic success.
Over the last 30 years or so, pay equity laws have been enacted across the country, requiring employers to identify female and male-dominated jobs, value the work performed and then address and eliminate any pay gaps. While enforcement was more aggressive during the early years, a new wave of enforcement efforts has started across the country.
The Ontario Equal Pay Coalition's 20th anniversary campaign
lead to renewed compliance efforts in that province, with most of the Pay Equity Act
applications coming from coalition member unions. Ontario's pay equity hearings tribunal has not yet fully mapped out employers' proactive maintenance obligations following the achievement of pay equity.
New employers are also being called to account for whether they opened their businesses "pay equity compliant" as required by Ontario's law. The tribunal will have its first opportunity to address the obligations of a new employer to involve its employees and bargaining agents in that process, provide necessary information and ensure pay equity is maintained. As Ontario's Act has no time limit for complaints, employers who have failed to achieve and maintain pay equity are liable for many years of pay equity adjustments, with interest regularly being ordered by the tribunal.
Human rights laws are also increasingly being used to advance pay equity rights. A recent Nova Scotia decision concluded that human rights, pay equity and employment standards statutes should be seen as complementary, with no statute "overpowering" the others. The board of inquiry decided that equal pay is a fundamental human right covered by the Nova Scotia Human Rights Act's
prohibition against sex discrimination in employment.
Another human rights decision in Quebec found that the right to equal pay guaranteed by s. 19 of Quebec's Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms
was violated when an employer retained a single-step salary progression system for male job classes, and a multi-step progression for comparable female job classes in a pay equity plan under Quebec's Pay Equity Act
. The tribunal held that employers must ensure their entire compensation or salary administration system is cleansed of discriminatory effects and that women are not required to wait longer than men to get to their highest job rate. Expert evidence was heard about the systemic practice of women's work often having longer wage grids than men's work.
This issue is now being litigated before the Ontario Tribunal in two cases - CUPE Local 1999 v. Lakeridge Hospital Corp. (PEHT#1788-09-PE) and CUPE Local 1734 v. York Region Board of Education (PEHT #1816-09-PE). With the delays involved in bringing a complaint first at Ontario's Review Services section of the Pay Equity Commission and then before the tribunal, employees and trade unions may consider bringing pay equity complaints directly to the reformed Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario as a new strategy for advancing pay equity claims.
Discriminatory pay practices for other disadvantaged workers are also being challenged. The 2004 federal Pay Equity Task Force highlighted the need to redress the pay discrimination faced by visible minorities, aboriginal people and persons with disabilities. In C.S.W.U. Local 111 v. SELI Canada,  B.C.H.R.T.D. No. 436, a B.C. human rights tribunal found that Latin American workers brought in on work visas were paid substantially less and provided with lesser accommodation, meal and expense arrangements compared to European workers performing the same work. The tribunal found the unequal pay and conditions to be discriminatory on the basis of race, colour, ancestry and place of origin, contrary to s. 13 of B.C.'s Human Rights Code
, and ordered the employer to pay the difference in the salaries between the employees, along with an additional award of $10,000 to each worker for injury to their dignity.
Pay equity rights are also at the centre of economic recovery efforts. As short-sighted employers push for smaller pay increases, freezes and cutbacks, women and their unions are relying on the mandatory pay equity obligations placed on employers to push back.
For example, the Harper government, as part of its budget austerity package, passed the Public Sector Equitable Compensation Act
(PSECA) in March 2009. The PSECA takes away the pay equity rights of federal public service women under the Canadian Human Rights Act
and instead leaves "equitable compensation" to collective bargaining. This law has been challenged as unconstitutional by several unions, including the Professional Institute of the Public Service (PIPSC et al v. Attorney General of Canada, Court File No. CV-09-375977).
The past success of unions in challenging attempts to curtail pay equity adjustments has lead to a recognition by some governments that economic recovery cannot come at the expense of pay equity. For example, a 1995 attempt by Ontario's government to repeal pay equity legislative rights was rejected as unconstitutional under s. 15 of the Charter (SEIU Local 204 v. AG (Ont.),  O.J. No. 3563). More than 10 years after the SEIU Charter challenge, Ontario's Public Sector Compensation Restraint to Protect Public Services Act, 2010, enacted in May, exempts pay equity and human rights adjustments from its wage freeze provisions.
With pay equity being pursued on so many legal fronts, Canada's pay gap should soon start to close.
Mary Cornish is the co-author of Enforcing Human Rights in Ontario. She works with Ryan White at the Toronto firm, Cavalluzzo, Hayes, Shilton, McIntyre & Cornish.
Canadian-Lawyers.ca-Powered by Lawyers.com is a great place to begin your search for a Labour and Employment lawyer in Canada